Find Italian Restaurants in Youngstown: A Local’s Guide to Italian Dining In Youngstown
Youngstown, Ohio, is a treasure trove of Italian culinary delights, offering an array of restaurants that serve up authentic Italian cuisine with passion and authenticity. Whether you’re looking for a cozy spot for a romantic dinner, a family-friendly venue, or a place to enjoy fine dining with a group of friends, Youngstown has something to offer. Here, we present an insider’s guide to the top 5 Italian restaurants in Youngstown, highlighting their unique features, location, and what makes them stand out in the realm of Italian dining.
1. Station Square Ristorante
Location: 4250 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH 44505
Price Range: $$ – $$$
Cuisine: Italian, American
Specialties: Seafood, Pasta, Risotto
Ambiance: Elegant, Relaxed
Notable Features: Extensive wine selection, online ordering available
Station Square Ristorante is a cornerstone in the Youngstown dining scene, renowned for its refined blend of Italian and American cuisine with a particular emphasis on exquisite seafood dishes. The ambiance at Station Square is one of understated elegance, providing a relaxed setting that is perfect for any occasion, from a casual lunch to a celebratory dinner. Signature dishes include scallops perfectly seared to a golden brown, creamy risotto, and pasta that transports you straight to Italy. The restaurant boasts an extensive wine list, ensuring that each dish can be paired with the perfect vintage.
2. Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza
Location: 6200 South Ave, Youngstown, OH 44512
Price Range: $
Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
Specialties: Wide variety of pizzas
Ambiance: Casual, Family-friendly
Notable Features: Affordable pricing, consistently delicious pies
Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza is a beloved local pizzeria that stands out for its commitment to quality and flavor. Here, pizza is not just food; it’s an art form. From the classic Margherita to more inventive creations, each pizza is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients that showcase the flavors of Italy. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere makes it a great spot for diners of all ages, and the affordable pricing means you can enjoy a delicious meal without breaking the bank.
3. Vernon’s Cafe
Location: 720 Youngstown Warren Rd, Niles, OH 44446
Price Range: $$ – $$$
Cuisine: Italian
Specialties: Traditional Italian dishes, Wine selection
Ambiance: Cozy, Intimate
Notable Features: Located a short drive from Youngstown, intimate dining experience
Just a stone’s throw from Youngstown in Niles, Vernon’s Cafe offers a cozy and intimate dining experience. This restaurant prides itself on serving traditional Italian dishes that are both comforting and sophisticated. The menu is a testament to the beauty of simplicity, with each dish allowing the quality of the ingredients to shine through. A carefully curated wine list complements the menu, making Vernon’s Cafe the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.
4. MVR
Location: 410 N Walnut St, Youngstown, OH 44505
Price Range: $$ – $$$
Cuisine: Italian
Specialties: Wedding soup, Fish sandwiches, Pasta
Ambiance: Warm, Family-friendly
Notable Features: Historic venue, diverse menu, outdoor seating
MVR, short for Mahoning Valley Restaurant, has a rich history and has been serving the Youngstown community for generations. Known for its welcoming atmosphere and hearty Italian fare, MVR is a place where families come together to celebrate life’s moments over good food. The menu features a mix of Italian-American classics, including the best wedding soup in town, fish sandwiches, and a variety of pasta dishes. The outdoor seating area adds a delightful option for dining al fresco during the warmer months.
5. The Elmton
Location: 584 5th St, Struthers, OH 44471
Price Range: $
Cuisine: Italian, American
Specialties: Pizza, Wings
Ambiance: Relaxed, Casual
Notable Features: Exceptional pizza, welcoming atmosphere, located just outside Youngstown
The Elmton, located in nearby Struthers, is renowned for its exceptional pizza and wings, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The relaxed, casual atmosphere is perfect for a laid-back evening out with friends or family. The Elmton’s pizzas are famous for their crispy crusts and generous toppings, each pie crafted with care and precision. It’s a testament to the simple joy of sharing a delicious pizza in good company.
These top 5 Italian restaurants in Youngstown offer more than just meals; they provide experiences that celebrate the rich flavors and warm hospitality of Italian dining. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit to any of these establishments promises an unforgettable culinary journey.
